SellerKitTools
Menu
Money Calculators

eBay Best Offer Strategy (2026): When to Accept, Counter, or Decline

By SellerKitTools Team · November 10, 2026 · 6 min read

eBay Best Offer Strategy (2026): When to Accept, Counter, or Decline illustration

eBay Best Offer strategy starts with one number, your floor price. Best Offer lets buyers on fixed price listings propose a price below your list price, and you can accept, decline, or counter. Without a floor decided before the first offer arrives, you negotiate against yourself and give away margin one small concession at a time. This guide covers the rules eBay enforces, how to set your auto accept and auto decline thresholds, and when to accept, counter, or walk away.

How eBay Best Offer works

Best Offer is an option you switch on for fixed price listings. It is unavailable in some categories, including cell phones, motors, real estate, tablets, and tickets. The offer applies to the item price only, so shipping and other listing terms stay as you set them.

RuleWhat eBay enforces
Seller response window24 hours, then the offer expires
Buyer offers per itemUp to 3 in most categories, 5 in vehicles
Counteroffer validity96 hours, or 4 days
Auto accept and auto declineOptional thresholds you set per listing

Expired, declined, and retracted offers all count toward the buyer's limit of 3. A buyer who opens at 50 percent of your price has only two more tries.

Set your floor price before you list

Your floor is the lowest sale price that still leaves you the profit you need: your item cost, plus the eBay final value fee, plus any shipping you absorb, plus the minimum profit you will accept. Work it out before you publish and write it in a private note on the listing.

Take a used camera lens listed at $100. You paid $40 for it and you cover $8 shipping. eBay's final value fee for most categories is 13.6 percent of the sale price. The math on three possible offers:

OffereBay fee (13.6%)Your net after cost and shipping
$90$12.24$29.76
$80$10.88$21.12
$70$9.52$12.48

If your minimum acceptable profit is $20, your floor is $79: at $79 the fee is $10.74 and your net is $20.26. At or above $79, accept. Below it, counter or decline.

When to accept, counter, or decline

Accept any offer at or above your floor, fast. An accepted offer is not a paid order until the buyer pays, and the item stays available to other buyers in the meantime. A quick accept keeps the buyer moving toward checkout instead of shopping around.

Counter once when the offer is close to your floor, within about 15 percent. Counter at the floor itself, not halfway to it, because a counter below your floor teaches the buyer your floor was negotiable. A $70 offer against a $79 floor gets one counter at $79. If the buyer comes back under the floor again, decline.

Decline without countering when the offer is far below your floor. A buyer at 50 percent of list price almost never climbs to your floor, and the exchange burns a day of your 24 hour response window. Use auto decline for these so you never see them. Lower the floor for items sitting unsold for 30 days with no watchers.

Auto accept and auto decline settings that work

Set auto accept at your floor, the lowest price you would happily take without seeing the offer. Set auto decline just below the lowest offer you would ever consider. Many sellers set auto accept around 85 to 90 percent of list price for common items, and 93 to 97 percent for rare items. Auto decline often sits around 65 to 70 percent of list price. These are rules of thumb, not eBay rules: your floor, built from your real costs, always wins over a percentage. Leave a gap between the two thresholds so offers in the middle still come to you for a manual decision.

When to turn Best Offer off

Turn Best Offer off when recent sold listings for the same item cluster in a narrow price band and your list price is already at the low end. The same goes for one of a kind items with tight comps. Keep it on for items with a wide range of sold prices, and for anything older than 30 days that you are willing to walk down to your floor without cutting the public price.

Quick answers

What is a good Best Offer percentage on eBay? A reasonable opening offer is usually 10 to 20 percent below list price. More than 40 percent below list price is a lowball unless the listing has sat unsold for weeks.

How many offers can a buyer make on eBay? Up to 3 offers per item in most categories, and 5 in vehicles categories. Expired, declined, and retracted offers count toward the limit.

Should I use auto accept on eBay? Yes, if you set it at your floor price, so good offers close while you are away. Never set it at a number you hope to renegotiate, because eBay accepts it instantly.

Check the math before you accept

Run the numbers in our free eBay fee calculator before you accept or counter any offer. Enter the offer price and your shipping cost, and see exactly what eBay keeps and what you keep.

Best Offer rules and eBay fee rates change from time to time. The 13.6 percent final value fee and the offer limits in this guide follow eBay's published US rules as of November 2026, so confirm the current rates in eBay Seller Hub before finalizing your floor.

Keep reading

How to Start Selling on Amazon (2026): Costs, Plans, and First Listing illustration
Money Calculators

How to Start Selling on Amazon (2026): Costs, Plans, and First Listing

How to start selling on Amazon comes down to six steps and two fees: this guide covers the $0.99 per item Individual plan, the $39.99 a month Professional plan, the 15 percent referral fee most categories charge, and a worked example for a $25 product.

Nov 16, 2026 · 7 min read

Amazon FBA Inventory Planning (2026): Avoid Stockouts and Storage Fees illustration
Money Calculators

Amazon FBA Inventory Planning (2026): Avoid Stockouts and Storage Fees

Amazon FBA inventory planning in one formula: how to set your reorder point, how much stock to send, and what overstocking costs in storage fees and aged inventory surcharges in 2026.

Nov 12, 2026 · 6 min read

How to Price Etsy Listings for Profit (2026): Fees, Shipping, and Margin illustration
Money Calculators

How to Price Etsy Listings for Profit (2026): Fees, Shipping, and Margin

A step by step pricing formula for Etsy sellers that covers materials, labor, overhead, and Etsy's 2026 fees, with a worked example.

Nov 8, 2026 · 6 min read

TikTok Shop Commission Rate Philippines: 0% for 90 Days Under SellerPlus (2026) illustration
Money Calculators

TikTok Shop Commission Rate Philippines: 0% for 90 Days Under SellerPlus (2026)

The TikTok Shop commission rate Philippines sellers pay is 0% for the first 90 days under SellerPlus, then 5% to 7.3% for Marketplace sellers, and this guide works through the full fee stack with a real order.

Nov 5, 2026 · 6 min read

Is an eBay Store Subscription Worth It (2026)? The Break-Even Math illustration
Money Calculators

Is an eBay Store Subscription Worth It (2026)? The Break-Even Math

An eBay store subscription pays for itself when your final value fee savings plus avoided insertion fees beat the monthly price, and the break-even math below shows exactly where that line sits for each tier.

Oct 31, 2026 · 7 min read

Amazon FBA Inbound Placement Fee (2026): What It Costs and How to Pay $0 illustration
Money Calculators

Amazon FBA Inbound Placement Fee (2026): What It Costs and How to Pay $0

The Amazon FBA inbound placement fee charges you for shipping to fewer fulfillment centers, and this guide shows the 2026 rates, the breakeven math, and how the Amazon-optimized split brings it to $0.

Oct 27, 2026 · 6 min read

How Etsy Payments Deposits Work (2026): Schedule, Fees, and Timing illustration
Money Calculators

How Etsy Payments Deposits Work (2026): Schedule, Fees, and Timing

How Etsy Payments deposits reach your bank: the daily to monthly schedule options, when funds become available after each sale, deposit minimums, and a worked $50 sale showing what actually lands.

Oct 23, 2026 · 6 min read

eBay Insertion Fees Explained (2026): Free Listings and How to Avoid Extra Charges illustration
Money Calculators

eBay Insertion Fees Explained (2026): Free Listings and How to Avoid Extra Charges

eBay insertion fees explained for 2026: every seller gets 250 free listings a month, then pays $0.35 per listing, with store allowances, a worked example, and how to avoid paying extra.

Oct 20, 2026 · 7 min read

eBay Promoted Listings Explained (2026): Are They Worth the Fee? illustration
Money Calculators

eBay Promoted Listings Explained (2026): Are They Worth the Fee?

eBay Promoted Listings cost 2% to 100% of the sale price, charged only when the ad leads to a sale within 30 days. See the real fee math with worked examples and a simple rule for when promoting pays off.

Oct 17, 2026 · 7 min read

FBA vs FBM (2026): Which Fulfillment Method Makes You More Money? illustration
Money Calculators

FBA vs FBM (2026): Which Fulfillment Method Makes You More Money?

The referral fee is identical either way, so FBA vs FBM comes down to one cost comparison plus the Prime, Buy Box, and control trade-offs, worked through with real numbers.

Oct 14, 2026 · 7 min read

Amazon Referral Fees by Category (2026): Full Table and Examples illustration
Money Calculators

Amazon Referral Fees by Category (2026): Full Table and Examples

The complete Amazon referral fee by category table for 2026, from the 15% standard to the tiered rates for clothing, beauty, jewelry, and furniture, with worked examples showing exactly what Amazon takes.

Oct 10, 2026 · 7 min read

Texas Moves to End Tax on Marketplace Fees (2026): What Amazon, eBay, and Etsy Sellers Save illustration
Money Calculators

Texas Moves to End Tax on Marketplace Fees (2026): What Amazon, eBay, and Etsy Sellers Save

On September 30, 2026, the Texas Comptroller ordered an end to the state's data processing tax on marketplace fees, which had taxed Amazon, eBay, and Etsy seller commissions since October 2025: what changed, what Texas sellers could save, and when the tax actually ends.

Oct 7, 2026 · 6 min read

Etsy Offsite Ads Explained (2026): Fees, Opt-Out Rules, and Whether They Are Worth It illustration
Money Calculators

Etsy Offsite Ads Explained (2026): Fees, Opt-Out Rules, and Whether They Are Worth It

What Etsy Offsite Ads actually cost: 15% or 12% of the order total, who can opt out, the $10,000 one-way threshold, and how to tell if they are worth it.

Oct 5, 2026 · 6 min read

Etsy Fees Explained (2026): How Much Does Etsy Really Take Per Sale? illustration
Money Calculators

Etsy Fees Explained (2026): How Much Does Etsy Really Take Per Sale?

Listing fees, transaction fees, payment processing, and offsite ads: every Etsy fee in plain English, with a worked example on a $30 sale.

Oct 2, 2026 · 7 min read

Amazon FBA Fees Breakdown (2026): Referral, Fulfillment, and Storage illustration
Money Calculators

Amazon FBA Fees Breakdown (2026): Referral, Fulfillment, and Storage

Referral fees, FBA fulfillment tiers, monthly storage, and the hidden extras: everything Amazon charges sellers, explained with a real example.

Sep 28, 2026 · 8 min read

eBay Selling Fees Explained (2026): Final Value Fees, Insertion Fees, and Real Examples illustration
Money Calculators

eBay Selling Fees Explained (2026): Final Value Fees, Insertion Fees, and Real Examples

eBay's 2026 fee schedule in plain English: final value fees by category, insertion fees, per-order fees, and what a $50 sale really costs you.

Sep 24, 2026 · 7 min read